| Colin Antonie | St Kilda 1969-71, 17 games, 7 goals |
| Jack Austin | St Kilda 1966, 6 games, 5 goals; Fitzroy 1968, 3 games, 1 goals |
| Trevor Barker | St Kilda 1975-89, 230 games 134 goals |
| Francis Biehl | South Melbourne 1910, 3 games, 1 goal |
| Peter Box | Footscray 1951-57, 107 games, 43 goals |
| William Butler | St Kilda 1942-46, 58 games, 0 goals |
| Colin Carter | St Kilda 1975-80, 49 games, 16 goals |
| Joseph Chandler | South Melbourne 1898, 3 games, 2 goals |
| Vaughan Ellis | Collingwood 1965-69, 19 games, 3 goals |
| John Hogan | Collingwood 1960, 2 games, 0 goals |
| Verdun Howell | St Kilda 1958-68, 159 games, 55 goals |
| John Hynes | Carlton 1998, 4 games, 2 goals |
| Brian Leary | Hawthorn 1950, 2 games, 0 goals |
| Steve Leehane | Carlton 1914-19, 82 games, 14 goals |
| Clarrie Lonsdale | Hawthorn 1927-37, 109 games, 22 goals |
| George Morrison | St Kilda 1897 and 1899, 6 games, 0 goals |
| Clem Neeson | Carlton 1936-37, 10 games, 2 goals; St Kilda 1937, 3 games, 0 goals |
| Neil Park | St Kilda 1982, 3 games, 5 goals |
| Ron Porta | Footscray 1953-59, 63 games 2 goals; Sth Melb 1960-61, 21 games, 0 goals |
| Edward Rippon | Essendon 1933-39, 69 games, 12 goals; St Kilda 1944-45, 17 games, 19 goals |
| Archie Roberts | Melbourne 1932-36, 36 games, 0 goals; Essendon 1937, 12 games, 0 goals |
| Kevin Roberts | St Kilda 1960-63 and 1965-69, 106 games, 110 goals |
| Arthur Rose | St Kilda 1937-40 and 1944, 28 games, 2 goals |
| Horrie Stanway | Footscray 1930-31, 20 games, 4 goals; Richmond 1931, 1 game, 0 goals |
| George Tanner | St Kilda 1942, 2 games, 0 goals |
| Ern Trickey | Fitzroy 1953-55, 12 games, 4 goals; South Melbourne 1957, 4 games, 4 goals |
